CoreLogic's House Price Index rose 0.5% in March, similar to January and February's muted gains, taking values 1.1% higher over the first quarter of 2024.
The average property value across NZ now stands at $934,806, up 3.2% ($29,361) from September's trough, but still 10.4% (-$108,455) below the recent peak.
The inconsistent nature of the upturn so far was evident again through March, with Wellington rising strongly (0.9%), and Christchurch, Dunedin and Auckland also showing gains (0.4-0.6%), but both Tauranga and Hamilton edging down 0.2%.
CoreLogic NZ Chief Property Economist, Kelvin Davidson, said the run of three softer results in a row at the national level was expected given stretched housing affordability.
"NZ's housing market can probably be described as 'not too hot, not too cold'," Mr Davidson said.
"High mortgage rates remain a big challenge at the forefront of all borrowers’ minds, whether they’re taking out a new loan or repricing an existing mortgage. While the new tax year and 80% mortgage interest deductions will help cashflow for property investors, it's unlikely to be enough to trump high interest rates.
“In addition, while the first official cash rate cut in the next cycle is getting closer, it’s certainly not here yet. Indeed, if the Reserve Bank’s current projections prove to be correct, the cash rate may not start to fall until next year, highlighting that shorter-term fixed mortgage rates may not drop much for at least another six to nine months.
“We’ve also seen a turnaround for listings activity in the first few months of 2024, with a good flow of fresh properties hitting the market, raising the choice for buyers and taking a bit of heat out of property prices. There’s no set definition, but the general sense is that the so-called sellers’ market of late 2023 has now switched back in favour of credit-approved purchasers,” Mr Davidson added.
Market performance was pretty variable across Auckland in March, with Rodney and North Shore both up by around 2%, but then a large gap back to broad stability in Auckland City, Waitakere, and Franklin, while values in Papakura and Manukau declined over the month.
There's also been inconsistent growth over the March quarter, with Rodney up more than 2%, but areas such as Waitakere only up very slightly (0.2%) and Papakura fractionally lower (-0.1%).
“Auckland's market is often seen as a bellwether for national trends, and although I'm a little sceptical of the degree to which patterns in our largest city genuinely 'filter out' to the regions, there's no doubt Auckland is currently demonstrating what's being seen elsewhere – an 'up and down' recovery," Mr Davidson said.
Indeed, digging beneath the surface in Wellington too, there's also clear evidence of variable performance. Upper Hutt, for example, spiked 2.3% in March, with Kapiti Coast and Wellington City also posting solid growth. However Lower Hutt and Porirua both saw values slide backwards.
"It's interesting to note the falls from the peak remain pretty large in Wellington, even after recent growth. Take Lower and Upper Hutt as examples, where values are still down from the peak by around 20% in both areas. That decline probably isn't doing much for the moods of homeowners who purchased at the tail-end of the boom, but on the flipside, it may present a good opportunity for prospective new buyers," Mr Davidson said.
Regional House Price Index results
Outside the main centres, March's data was also a mixed bag, with Invercargill, New Plymouth, Napier, and Rotorua all rising by at least 1%, but Gisborne and Queenstown dropping 1.2% apiece.
Given the broad (albeit slow) upturn has now been in progress for around six months, a number of regional markets have seen their annual house price growth rates turn positive. Hastings, Invercargill, and Queenstown have seen annual gains of around 3% or more, however Gisborne, Whangarei, and Nelson are still around 2% (or more) below the levels from a year ago.
Mr Davidson said there's always local variation in house price trends, even when the wider market nationally is booming.
"It's no surprise that some regions are rising more strongly than others in this current 'testing' market, while some are still actually falling. The general trend should remain upwards in the coming months, but it's unlikely to be a straight line everywhere."
Property market outlook
Looking ahead, Mr Davidson said there are certainly still challenges in play for the housing market.
"March’s subdued property value data is a timely reminder that this upturn may well be inconsistent from month to month, and across regions,” he said.
“Certainly, although house sales volumes are now trending higher, they’re coming off a very low base, and activity remains well below normal. In that environment, it’s no surprise that value patterns are also a bit patchy.
"First home buyers continue to target the market, and have been a great success story in the past 12-18 months, using KiwiSaver for at least part of the deposit, and making full use of the low deposit lending allowances at the banks. But other buyer groups, such as mortgaged investors, remain more subdued.
“Sales volumes remain on track to rise by about 10% this calendar year and property values by perhaps 5% nationally – decent figures, but slow by past standards," Mr Davidson concluded.
Download the House Price Index data
Meet Kelvin Davidson
Chief Economist
Kelvin joined CoreLogic in March 2018 as Senior Research Analyst, before moving into his current role of Chief Economist. He brings with him a wealth of experience, having spent 15 years working largely in private sector economic consultancies in both New Zealand and the UK.
Full profile